Understanding Insurance for Real Estate Investors

Bonus Module

Insurance is a critical part of protecting your real estate investments and for asset protection.

As a real estate investor, understanding the different types of coverage, how insurance policies work, and how to make informed decisions can save you from significant financial loss.

Below, we’ll dive into the essential aspects of insurance to help you safeguard your properties and investment strategy.

Table of Contents

Included below:

• Understanding Insurance for Real Estate Investors

• Penny-Wise Pound-Foolish

• Insurance Tips

• Strong Relationships

• Understanding the Business of Insurance

• Captive vs Independent Insurance Agents

• Insurance Policies Are Like Snowflakes

• Read and Understand Your Policy

• Beware of Jargon

• Should You Make a Claim?

• Maximize Coverage

• Umbrella Policy

• The Price of Protection: Understanding Umbrella Coverage

• Not Insuring for the Amount of Your Equity

• Compare Premium/Deductible

• Extra Coverage

• Replacement Cost

• Replacement Cost: Dwelling

• Replacement Cost: Roof

• Replacement Cost: Contents

• Require Renter Policies from Tenants

• Other Insurance

• Getting Insurance

• Final Insurance Tips

Penny-Wise Pound-Foolish

When it comes to insurance, don’t make the mistake of focusing only on the lowest rate. Sure, it’s tempting to save a few bucks, but cutting corners on coverage can leave you exposed to massive costs down the road. Unless you plan to essentially self-insure, meaning you’re ready to cover any major expenses out of pocket, you need to consider more than just the price tag.

Start by thinking about what you want out of your insurance policy.

• What Do You Want Covered? - Are you only looking for basic coverage, or do you need something more comprehensive? Does your policy cover things like liability, loss of rental income, or damage from natural disasters?

• What Are You Willing to Take On Yourself? - Are you comfortable handling minor repairs or issues, or do you want your insurance to cover as much as possible? The more you’re willing to handle yourself, the less coverage you might need—but that comes with risk.

The time to decide all of this is now, before something happens. If you wait until disaster strikes, it’s too late. And remember, if you have a loan on the property, insurance isn’t just protecting you—it’s protecting the lender too. They’ll usually require you to have adequate coverage. However, if your property is free and clear, you have the option to go without insurance, but that means you’re taking on all the risk.

In short, don’t be penny-wise and pound-foolish with your insurance. Make sure you’re covered for the things that matter most to you and your investments.

Insurance Tips

These are the key insurance tips we’re going to cover to help you protect your real estate investments effectively:

• Develop Strong Relationship With Your Insurance Agent and Understand Your Coverage - Building a good relationship with your agent ensures you get the right coverage and advice.

• Limit Claims Close to Deductible Amount - Avoid filing small claims that could raise your premiums or get your policy canceled.

• Maximize Liability Coverage on Properties and Autos - Make sure your liability limits are high enough to protect you from large claims.

• Umbrella Policy - An umbrella policy provides additional liability protection beyond your regular coverage.

• Compare Premium/Deductible (Especially for Deal Analysis) - Finding the right balance between premium and deductible is crucial for managing costs.

• Extra Coverages Like Sewer Backup, Loss Assessment Coverage, etc. - Consider adding specific coverages to protect against unique risks.

• Replacement versus Actual Cash Value - Understand the difference between these two payout methods to ensure you're covered properly.

• Require Renter Policies From Your Tenants - Protect yourself by requiring tenants to have renter’s insurance for their belongings and liability.

Strong Relationships

Having strong relationships with key members of your real estate investing dream team, including your insurance agent, is essential. Your agent plays a critical role in making sure you have the right coverage both now and as your portfolio grows or your needs change.

They can help explain the different coverages available, what they cost, and what risks you’re taking by not having certain policies. They should also be able to walk you through the situations these policies cover and give you an idea of how likely those events are to happen.

Beyond setting up your policies, a good insurance agent can assist you when deciding whether to make a claim. They can help you understand the potential impact of filing a claim on your premiums or your ability to keep coverage.

When you do need to file a claim, having an agent you trust means they’ll guide you through the process and help ensure you get paid smoothly.

A strong relationship with your insurance agent isn’t just about policies—it’s about having someone who understands your real estate business. They should be proactive, keeping you informed about changes in the market or new risks that could affect your investments.

The right agent will help you navigate all of this, ensuring you’re always covered where it matters most.

Understanding the Business of Insurance

Imagine you wanted to start a business selling insurance. You’d go out, collect money from people, and promise that if a specific event happens—like their house burning down or someone getting injured on their property—you will pay a defined amount to cover the loss.

The money you collect from your customers is called premiums. The money you pay out when an event occurs is called claims.

To run an insurance business, you need to collect more in premiums than you pay out in claims. But that’s not enough. You also have to cover your operating expenses and make a profit—after all, why start the business otherwise?

You need to pay people to figure out how often these events happen and how much they’ll cost when they do. You’ll also need salespeople to bring in customers, claims handlers, CPAs to manage taxes, attorneys to draft policies, and more.

As the cost of covered events rises—like the cost to rebuild a house or the medical bills for an injury—the insurance company will need to raise premiums to stay profitable. If events like natural disasters or accidents start happening more frequently, they’ll need to adjust the premiums again.

Now, from the customer’s perspective, if you didn’t have insurance and your house burned down, you’d have to pay the full rebuild cost—possibly hundreds of thousands of dollars. But, with insurance, you might pay just $1,000 per year, and if your house happens to be the one that burns down, the insurance company will pay to rebuild it.

Let’s say the insurance company collects $300,000 in premiums from 300 customers, but one house burns down. They pay $200,000 to rebuild that house. Now, they only have $100,000 left to cover operating expenses and make a profit. If two houses burn down that year, the company might actually lose money.

For the customer, you’re essentially paying into a pool. If something bad happens, you hope to get more money out of the pool than you put in. Some customers won’t ever need to make a claim, and that’s great—it means nothing bad happened. Others will, and if that’s you, it’s bad that something happened, but good that you’ve got insurance to help cover the cost.

Captive vs Independent Insurance Agents

When choosing an insurance agent, it's important to understand the difference between captive and independent agents.

Each type offers different benefits, so knowing which one works best for you can help ensure you get the right coverage.

• Captive Agents - These agents work exclusively for one insurance company and can only sell that company's policies.

• Independent Agents - These agents work with multiple insurance companies and can offer you a range of policy options from different providers.

Pros and Cons of Captive Agents

Captive agents are often more knowledgeable about the products of the company they represent. They can offer you in-depth advice on the specific coverages available through that insurer.

However, their options are limited to what their company offers, which means you may not always get the best deal or the most suitable coverage for your real estate investments.

Captive agents are also incentivized to keep you within their company’s offerings, which could lead to higher costs or fewer choices if your insurance needs change.

Pros and Cons of Independent Agents

Independent agents, on the other hand, can shop around for you. Since they work with multiple insurers, they can compare different policies and find the one that best fits your needs as a real estate investor. This can save you both time and money, as they are not tied to any one company’s offerings.

The downside is that independent agents might not have the same depth of knowledge about specific products as captive agents do. Their focus is often spread across many different insurers, so they may not be able to provide the same level of detail about each policy.

For real estate investors, independent agents often offer the flexibility to find policies that better match your changing needs. But if you prefer to stick with one company for simplicity, a captive agent might be a better fit.

Insurance Policies Are Like Snowflakes

No two insurance policies are exactly alike. Each one is unique, and it's important to carefully read and compare your policies because they are not standardized.

You can’t just shop by price alone. Different policies cover different things, and the fine print matters. One policy might seem cheaper, but it could leave you exposed in areas where another policy provides better coverage. The way they describe what’s covered can significantly impact what happens when you need to file a claim.

The way the insurance company handles claims also matters. You want to know how they respond when something goes wrong. Will they be easy to work with, or will they make the claims process difficult?

In short, the details of your policy are everything.

Make sure you understand exactly what you're getting, and don’t assume all policies are the same just because they look similar on the surface. Each insurance policy is unique—just like snowflakes.

Read and Understand Your Policy

It’s crucial to read and fully understand your insurance policy so you know exactly what is and isn’t covered. Relying on assumptions can lead to unpleasant surprises if you ever need to make a claim.

You can—and probably should—ask your insurance agent for help. This is one of the major benefits of having a dedicated agent. They can walk you through the policy, explain any confusing terms, and help you understand your coverage.

If your agent can’t or won’t help you understand your policy, it might be time to reconsider if they belong on your dream team. You’ll need to weigh whether staying with a company that has a less-than-helpful agent is worth it, or if it makes sense to pay a little more for an agent who provides better service. Alternatively, you might find a different agent within the same company who’s more willing to assist.

If you’re trying to save money by going without an agent, keep in mind that you’ll need to take on the responsibilities an agent would normally handle. This means you’ll need to read and understand the policy yourself, as well as handle any issues that come up.

Beware of Jargon

Insurance companies often use their own language or jargon to describe coverage options. For example, you might see terms like "silver" or "gold" plans. These names can be misleading because they aren’t standardized—what one company calls a "gold plan" could be completely different from another company’s "gold plan."

Be aware of these terms and don’t assume they mean the same thing across different insurers. Ask your agent to explain your policy in everyday language. You should understand exactly what’s covered without needing to interpret the company’s marketing language.

Take the time to dig into the true meaning behind terms like Platinum, Gold, Silver, or even Ultimate, Optimum, Select. These terms might sound impressive, but what matters is what’s actually included in the coverage. Always clarify the details before making a decision.

Should You Make a Claim?

Before rushing to file a claim, take a moment to weigh the short-term benefits against the potential long-term consequences. Filing a claim may seem like the obvious choice when something goes wrong, but it could lead to higher costs down the road.

What if your insurance company decides to cancel your policy or refuses to renew it? This could leave you scrambling to find a new insurer—one that might charge higher premiums or offer less favorable coverage.

Consider the broader impact of making claims. Not only could your rates increase for the policy in question, but it could also affect other policies you hold with the same company. Is it worth the risk for smaller claims, or should you save insurance for larger, more catastrophic events?

Ask yourself how you view insurance: Are you using it to file a claim for every minor issue? Or do you see it as a safety net for bigger, less frequent problems?

When thinking about your deductible, decide how much over that amount would justify a claim. Would you file a claim for just a penny over your deductible? Or would it need to be $500 over? Twice the amount? Three times the amount?

By reducing the frequency of claims, you can help keep your premiums low and maintain your ability to stay insured. Use insurance wisely to protect yourself in the long run.

Maximize Coverage

Maximizing your insurance coverage is essential for protecting your real estate investments from large, unexpected events. Here are some typical coverages you might see on a property and what they protect you from:

• Property Coverage - Protects your building and structures from damage, such as fire, theft, or vandalism.

• Liability Coverage - Protects you if someone is injured on your property and decides to sue.

• Flood or Earthquake Coverage - Provides protection for natural disasters not included in standard policies.

Having sufficient coverage means that if something catastrophic happens, like a major lawsuit, your insurance can help cover the costs. Let’s walk through a detailed example to show how coverage, or lack of it, can impact your financial situation as a real estate investor.

Extreme Example: Balcony Collapse

Imagine you own a rental property with significant equity—let’s say you have $500,000 in equity between this property and others. During a gathering, the balcony collapses, injuring several people and tragically resulting in one fatality. The victims and their families file a lawsuit against you for negligence, with the total claims amounting to $2 million.

Now, let's explore three scenarios: no insurance, under-insured, and adequately insured.